What a pain. Imagine you are in Windows network environment and have a small amount of Ubuntu desktops. You task is to let them join the Active Directory so users can login with their known credentials. There is a package in universe called “authtool” even providing and promising to do what you need. Sadfully it is quite broken in it’s current status and if you ask me one should even consider removing it until it does at least not break you boot (don’t ask for details) and has a good set of working dependencies. There are other methods as ldap-binding but in my eyes there are either not stable or just too complicated to configure (and therefore hardly qualified for convincing people).
But a solution approaches if you read the following Ubuntu blueprint “Single User Interface to Join and Participate in Microsoft Active Directory Domains“. Currently you might not find much more information about it. So I dropped a line to the blueprint creator Gerald ‘Jerry’ Carter who was so kind of updating me with the current status of the project (and happens to be directly involved in Likewise):
It is planned to package the open source version of Likewise called “Likewise Open” for Ubuntu Hardy. Likewise Open enables you to join an Active Directory with actually some simple clicks or one console command. There is already an updated source tarball which can be installed quite easily:
1 2 3 4 5
$ wget \http://archives.likewisesoftware.com/\ likewise-open/src/likewise-open-4.0.4.tar.gz $ tar zxf likewise-open-4.0.4.tar.gz $ cd likewise-open-4.0.4-release $ make dpkg
If you have all necessary dependencies resolved the make process should provide you with .deb files which you should install. As Jerry states there is currently one blocker which can be worked by not using the gui but calling a line like this
$ sudo domainjoin-cli join AD_REALM ADMIN_ACCOUNT
Afterwards you should be able to login like this “realm\username”. I tried the process on Gutsy and it worked quite well. I had to reboot once as my gdm hang – maybe it’s better to call the command directly from a “real” console. So what is missing? Check the comparison of Likewise Open and Likewise Enterprise, the commercial version of Likewise. The thing you might miss at first is:
Do more during logon: Create a home directory, copy template files, set permissions, run scripts, deliver messages, and more.
This means that Likewise Open enables you to login as AD user, creates his home under /local/AD_REALM/USER but you have be smart and hack around a bit to get things working like managing sudo, running scripts and so on. But nonetheless Likewise Open seems to be a promising approach for solving the problem of Ubuntu-Windows-network integration and I am sure to see some nice addons from the community in the future.
Please note: Installing software that changes login procedures is a deep intervention into Linux core procedures. So please: Do this with a test environment before considering it for production purposes.